Will Foggy Thinking Sink Playoff?

Unless some clear thinking comes along, the four team playoff will only be half as bad as the BCS Championship.  The selection process labors under a number of myths, starting with the ridiculous idea that a win is a win is a win.  

Notre Dame rode questionable calls and narrow wins to a #1 ranking.

Kevin Cline

Notre Dame rode questionable calls and narrow wins to a #1 ranking.

In considering a hypothetical four-team playoff for last year, John Canzano labeled undefeated Notre Dame a shoo-in.  A win makes all the difference in whether Saturday night’s brew is to celebrate or drown sorrows, but to ignore decisiveness of wins is a recipe for disaster when judging readiness for a national championship. In 2012, Notre Dame struggled to beat five mediocre teams: Purdue, 20-17; Michigan, 13-6; BYU, 17-14; Pitt 29-26; and beat-up, Barkley-less USC, 22-13.  Had Oregon and Kansas State not stumbled, the Irish would have been in the championship game ahead of Alabama, who had one bad day against a strong Texas A & M team that played lights out — seven days after Notre Dame slipped past 2-10 Pitt in triple overtime.  ARMY beat Pitt!  

No team brings its ‘A’ game every week.  Sometimes teams play over their heads.  So, to be serious about picking the best two (or four) teams, a more sensible approach is to throw out each team’s best and worst performances and see what’s left.  For Notre Dame, you’re left with too many unimpressive wins over mediocre opponents.  For Alabama, you have two close wins over Top Five teams and double-digit wins everywhere else.  For Oregon you have double-digit wins across the board.  Looking at it that way, you wouldn’t think Notre Dame would have had much of a chance.  They didn’t – and until any selection process looks deeper than the win-loss records, it won’t either.  

Print Friendly
Mike Merrell

Mike Merrell

Mike (Editor-in-Chief) is a 1970 graduate of the University of Oregon where he attended the Honors College and received all-conference honors as a swimmer. After college, Mike ran for the Oregon Track Club and narrowly missed qualifying for the US Olympic Trials in the marathon. He continues his involvement in sports with near-daily swimming or running workouts, occasional masters swim competition (where he has received two Top-10 World rankings), providing volunteer coaching to local triathletes and helping out with FishDuck.com. Mike lives on 28 acres in the forest near Sandpoint, Idaho, where he has served as a certified public accountant for most of his working career. His current night job is writing novels about Abby Westminster, the only known illegitimate daughter of Britain's finest secret agent who has to bring down arch-villains plotting dastardly deeds. And, yes, Abby is also a DUCK!

  • Jason Curtis

    Come on now, you are talking common sense here. We’ll have none of that in the NCAA. It is much simpler if we just say “when Notre Dame wins they’re in!”