Chip Kelly Update: Front Office Thunderdome

Marcus running rampant

For the first time ever in his head coaching career, Chip Kelly’s season ended when the regular season did. It’s got to be killing him, as proud as he no doubt is that his Ducks destroyed Florida State and are heading into the National Championship Game favored by a touchdown.

As I’ve said before, he’s Moses, unable to enter the Promised Land and watching his people go on without him. Bittersweet.

Asked if he would attend the Rose Bowl game against Florida State, Kelly told reporters he had work to do but would try to make the big show at AT&T Stadium. Within a couple of days, we learned what he meant by “work to do.”

It's all fun and games until someone gets promoted

from video (NFL Rewind)

It’s all fun and games until someone gets promoted.

My last column detailed the Byzantine power struggles that week in which GM Howie Roseman fired Kelly’s ally, Player Personnel Director Tom Gamble — followed two days later by Roseman getting kicked upstairs to a VP job with no power over roster selection. He’s still in charge of contracts, free agent re-signings, and the salary cap, though, and that’s a big concern going forward. It’s a bad idea to have someone in such a key role with lots of reason to resent, and possibly undercut, the coach.

Another week has failed to clarify everything that went down, but three of the Eagles’ beat writers presented compelling (if somewhat speculative) visions that are worth reading if you like this kind of manly soap opera.

Geoff Mosher of CSN Philly painted a dark and compelling portrait that rings true but leaves me worried about future conflict between Kelly and Roseman, whom former staff paint as shrewd but paranoid.

The idea that Kelly and Roseman are out of each other’s way now is absurd. They still have to work together when it comes to player retention, free-agent signings and other areas where money and personnel blend.

What happens when Kelly wants to keep a player Roseman believes is overvalued?

GM Howie Roseman explaining

from video (Philadelphia

GM Howie Roseman explaining

At least Mosher has good — heck, downright ecstatic — things to say about Ed Maryonwitz (pronounced “manowitz”), the Eagles’ very young assistant director of player personnel. Maryonwitz was the first candidate named as Roseman’s potential replacement. At 30, though, he seems too young to earn the respect of other GMs around the NFL.

On a lighter but no less shrewd note, the Inquirer’s Bob Ford had great fun ridiculing the idea that Roseman was promoted.

As his parting gift from the world of real power in the organization, Roseman got a shiny new title, a contract extension, and as much tinsel as the team could publicly layer onto his demotion.

The announcement read like a come-on for a gas station opening, the kind that promises “prizes, balloons, and more.” Roseman will continue to handle contract negotiations; salary-cap management; and NFL strategic matters; as well as overseeing “the team’s medical staff, equipment staff, and more.”

And more! Not that sorting out a pesky hip-pad issue in the equipment room wouldn’t be enough to satisfy any eager executive on a job well done, but Roseman will get to do even more.

And finally, a new recap by the Inquirer’s Zach Berman confirms the paranoia part of Mosher’s portrait. He quotes an ex-employee as saying that “Howie is motivated by fear” (of missing great prospects, of not being the best) and offers a concise summary of Roseman’s talents and limits:

“He could tell you that a guy would go in the second round — he couldn’t tell you if that player would be good,” a former team employee said.

Knowing the draft value of a player you want is incredibly helpful. But will Roseman be willing to help Kelly look good, after the coach pushed him out of his dream job? We’ll know a lot more by May 2 when the last pick is in.

What were we talking about? I got distracted

By Neon Tommy (CC BY-SA 2.0)

What were we talking about? I got distracted.

Speaking of the draft, I had — like most Eagles writers — written off the prospect of Philadelphia picking up Marcus Mariota as a pipe dream, given that he’s projected as the first or second choice in the draft, and the Eagles choose at #20. There’s just no way to move up that far.

Then, Thursday, Trent Dilfer — the Superbowl-winning quarterback and current ESPN analyst — said the words I long to hear:

I’m not completely from the school of thought that Marcus is going to go in those top two, three, four or five picks. I think there’s a chance he may slide a little bit as this goes. If he gets into that eight, nine, 10 (spot), or even early teens, there may be an opportunity for Philly to go get him if they want him that bad.

It sounds too good to be true, but just look at last year’s draft. Teddy Bridgewater and Johnny Manziel were both projected #1 pick at one point, before falling way down the draft board. The Eagles passed on Manziel at #22, trading away the pick, and Bridgewater barely made the first round at 32, even though many teams now wish they had picked him much higher.

The bottom line is that these valuations jump all over the place. A national championship won’t diminish Mariota’s luster, but a shaky combine or even just NFL conventional wisdom about “pro style quarterbacks” who need to play in the pocket and hit tight windows, might do the trick.

I hate to get my hopes up, but Mariota has reason to like the idea. Philadelphia has a good offensive line to protect him and a system he thrives in.

All Marcus has to do is run a slow 40 at the Combine, or get caught with hookers in an opium den a couple of times before May, and all of our dreams may yet come true. And Chip might enter the Promised Land after all.

Top photo by Kevin Cline

Print Friendly

 Volunteer Position Openings:

--Media Management/Supervisor:  We are looking for someone beyond college age who can help manage students and mentor in a number of different departments. Expertise is not required as organizational skills and interest in guiding others.   --Assistant Football Analyst: Love college football and enjoy watching it for hours? We need associates to view games and find the techniques/teaching points we identify for them in advance.  You will be recognized in publications, and could have the opportunity to move to full Analyst.   --College Football Analyst: We are looking for Coaches, or retired coaches to help create analysis videos (we do the video part) that will be viewed by thousands, and will help young football players as well as fans understand the game much better. The national recognition will help your resume' as well as make an impact upon the game we all dearly love.   --Video Specialist: We are looking for help in the Eugene/Springfield area to assist with the shooting and editing of analysis videos.   All Positions: Send a resume' with full contact information and any writing samples you have to  Again, these are volunteer positions donating five hours a week each.

Mark Saltveit

Mark Saltveit

Mark Saltveit's newest book is "Controlled Chaos: Chip Kelly's Football Revolution" (Diversion Books, NY) has been recently released. He is the author of "The Tao of Chip Kelly" (2013) and writes on science, religion, wordplay and political scandals. He is also a standup comedian and the world palindrome champion.


    I would certainly not value anything a 3rd string QB at best who was lucky to play for a RAVENS Team that had no doubt the best Defense in a long time. His job was just to manage the Game and He wishes he had the talent of Marcus Mariota and make no BONE’S about it Mariota will be drafted 1st come draft day. Look at Tampa Bay as in they are a talented Team everywhere but QB and make no mistake about it Marcus is very very smart as in Football IQ. If anyone thinks Mariota can’t come in and learn any offense then do not consider yourself Football intelligent because your not. Marcus has every intangible required to be a ALL PRO QB at the next level. He is better than Winston any day of the week. I seriously doubt because of the off field issues that Winston’s done is this, why would anyone waste a 1st round pick on a guy that sounds like when he speaks he has around a 6th Grade education because there is no way he’s done any class time at FSU to make him intelligent because he’s far from it! Cleveland Browns drafted Manziel because it was the Owner that wanted him and what a stupid move because he wanted to sale tickets. I say for how long because Manziel wont even be a 3rd string QB after 3 to 4 more seasons he will be out of the league because he cannot play SANDLOT Football in the BIG League’s. Marcus will dispel everything said about spread option QB’s being able to play at the next level.

  • hokieduck

    Ok, Mark. You and Darren Carrington can come out of the backroom now. Cough. Cough.

    Just like you, I would *love* to see Marcus slide to a spot where he could reasonably be picked up by Chip. That is simply not going to happen. He may or may not succeed in the NFL. But he is not going to slide out of the top ten. Never going to happen.

    The only way I see Chip ever having a chance at Marcus is in a trade or as a FA signing. But you know far more than I.

    Go Ducks! Beat the Bucks! WTD!

    • Mark Saltveit

      All I’m saying is, if he slides to 10, that becomes a do-able trade down to 20 for the Eagles. at 1 or 2 it’s not conceivable.

      But it’s true he hasn’t had to hit tight windows from the pocket or play in a WCO or other pro-style offense. For all non-Chip Kelly teams, that creates a risk that he might not be able to adapt. So he is worth less to other teams than the Eagles.

      That creates a trading opportunity. Future picks? Brandon Graham (after resigning him), this year’s one and a couple of cheesesteaks?