Selective Memory Loss Targets College Football

usc, USC,12,KH

Mike Merrell’s Three-and-Out

Memory loss is something we all suffer from time to time. It can be everything from entertaining to life-threatening, but for most of us it’s usually just embarrassing — the times we can’t quite put the name with the face fast enough — or frustrating — Now what did I come into this room for?

Here's one we'd all like to forget.

Here’s a guy we’d all like to forget.

But when people actually have time to think things over and they just can’t seem to find the wherewithal to consider the obvious it is downright perplexing. Like Jameis Winston’s “coulda went either way” after a 59-20 shellacking in the Rose Bowl. Right. I guess we should just forget about those six turnovers that led to Oregon touchdowns.

With a generous dose of selective memory (accidental or otherwise) we can convince ourselves of all kinds of things. But it’s just not a good idea to make decisions based upon what we choose to forget — and some of those forgotten things is the subject of this week’s Three-and-Out.

1. Eastern Washington football coach Beau Baldwin. No coach likes to see his star player move to another team, especially the next team up on his schedule, so Beau was understandably not happy when quarterback Vernon Adams announced his intent to transfer to Oregon after completing his undergraduate degree, as allowed by NCAA rules.

As quoted by the Spokesman Review’s John Blanchette, Beau said, “I don’t see myself finding my next quarterback at Linfield.” Linfield, it seems, plays a division lower than Eastern Washington, and I guess the idea was supposed to be that there should be at least some unwritten rule against dipping down to steal stars.

Beau Baldwin says transfers to Big Sky good, from Big Sky evil.

from video

Beau Baldwin says transfers to Big Sky good, from Big Sky evil.

What Beau has — oops — forgotten is that while he hasn’t gone to Linfield to get a quarterback, he has taken a wide receiver from Whitworth, which is in the same conference as Linfield. Maybe I’m not seeing the right way to split hairs here, but perhaps he’s proposing an NCAA rule that says that it’s okay for wide receivers to transfer, but not quarterbacks?

And apparently it’s also okay for players to transfer to Eastern from Pac-12 schools, since he has no less than seven former Pac-12 players on his roster. It’s apparently just not okay for players to transfer from the Big Sky to the Pac-12 — even after they’ve put in their four years and earned their degrees.

The rule that allows players to transfer after achieving an undergraduate degree is a good rule, because it puts academics first. It accentuates the importance of getting that degree — which is a good thing to do considering the average NFL career is a mere 3.3 years long — and it provides the opportunity to pursue a graduate degree at a different university, which provides for a better rounded education.

2. Marcus Mariota vs. Jameis Winston as the higher pick. If any NFL team picks Winston ahead of Mariota, it will get what it deserves, and that is probably not a good thing. The things Winston has done to draw question to his maturity, judgment and values are too many to mention.

There is no competition between Mariota ...

Jim Shurtleff

There is no competition between Mariota …

But if somebody in charge of making that draft pick needed a reminder of who not to pick, Winston gave it to them when, as reported in this article on WEEI.com, he announced, “I’m not into no competition type of thing. I’m in it to win games and be the face of someone’s franchise. This is no competition between just me and Mariota, because one thing about me, I plan on winning the Super Bowl next year so it’s going to be me vs. Peyton Manning and Jameis vs. Tom Brady.

...and Winston.

Craig Strobeck

…and Winston.

It’s funny that Winston should mention Peyton Manning. Like Mariota and Winston this year, in the 1998 draft, there was debate over which of two quarterbacks would go first — Peyton Manning or Ryan Leaf. Manning, like Mariota, came out of college with exemplary character. Leaf, like Winston — not so much. The Colts took Manning with the first pick, and like the Energizer Bunny, he’s still going. Leaf had behavior problems — four years, four different teams and gone.

But even if you want to forget all of that and believe that Winston is the better choice because he’s a more accurate passer, there is the issue that Mariota threw for 42 touchdowns against four picks in 2014 while Winston hit paydirt only 25 times while finding receivers wearing the wrong colored jerseys 18 times. But maybe it’s not an accuracy issue, maybe it’s just a judgment issue.

And judgment can be taught? Maybe, but claiming to be in the same class as Manning and Brady and claiming that you’re going to win a Super Bowl next year before you even know what team you’re on seems like a bad start.

So maybe what Winston should be saying is, “This is no competition between just me and Mariota, because one thing about me… it’s going to be me vs. Ryan Leaf.”

3. USC # 4? The next time ESPN’s Mark Schlabach has occasion to introduce his wife, I hope he can remember her name, because Schlabach, who picked USC as the top Pac-12 team (and #4 in the country) for 2015, obviously has memory issues.

As near as he can remember, Mark Schlabach has USC at #4 for 2015.

from video

As near as he can remember, Mark Schlabach has USC at #4 for 2015.

The Trojans, who always look better on paper than on the field, somehow duped the entire AP Poll in 2012, and were selected #1 in the preseason rankings. True to form, the Trojans finished that year a ho-hum 7-6, which didn’t even come close to cracking the Top 25.

Ah, but that was 2012 and this is 2015 and the Trojans just got the top ranked recruiting class, and they have the top returning Pac-12 quarterback, and… and… and…

And they have Steve Sarkisian as their coach. The smart money that has any memory at all behind it has the Trojans blowing a few games here and there. Sarkisian has yet to prove that he can coach at the highest level, and all those top Trojan recruits have yet to prove that they can build on their high school press clippings.

Top photo (USC 2012) by Kaly Harwood

Print Friendly

 Volunteer Position Openings:

--Media Management/Supervisor:  We are looking for someone beyond college age who can help manage students and mentor in a number of different departments. Expertise is not required as organizational skills and interest in guiding others.   --Assistant Football Analyst: Love college football and enjoy watching it for hours? We need associates to view games and find the techniques/teaching points we identify for them in advance.  You will be recognized in publications, and could have the opportunity to move to full Analyst.   --College Football Analyst: We are looking for Coaches, or retired coaches to help create analysis videos (we do the video part) that will be viewed by thousands, and will help young football players as well as fans understand the game much better. The national recognition will help your resume' as well as make an impact upon the game we all dearly love.   --Video Specialist: We are looking for help in the Eugene/Springfield area to assist with the shooting and editing of analysis videos.   All Positions: Send a resume' with full contact information and any writing samples you have to charles@fishduck.com  Again, these are volunteer positions donating five hours a week each.

Mike Merrell

Mike Merrell

Mike (Editor-in-Chief) is a 1970 graduate of the University of Oregon where he attended the Honors College and received all-conference honors as a swimmer. After college, Mike ran for the Oregon Track Club and narrowly missed qualifying for the US Olympic Trials in the marathon. He continues his involvement in sports with near-daily swimming or running workouts, occasional masters swim competition (where he has received two Top-10 World rankings), providing volunteer coaching to local triathletes and helping out with FishDuck.com. Mike lives on 28 acres in the forest near Sandpoint, Idaho, where he has served as a certified public accountant for most of his working career. His current night job is writing novels about Abby Westminster, the only known illegitimate daughter of Britain's finest secret agent who has to bring down arch-villains plotting dastardly deeds. And, yes, Abby is also a DUCK!

  • goober mcsnee

    great article… character counts – lots of talented folks out there who blow themselves up without achieving their potential… character helps win the day..

  • Nw Football Fan

    On the Baldwin piece, the Whitworth transfer wasn’t reqruited, he chose toe transfer and walk on. The players who transfer down were either on the verge of being excused from their program or had lost their starting position and wanted more playing time. The issue at hand is that actively offering a scholarship to starting from another school to compete to be a starter for you is a little unethical. Yes he is on track to graduate and it is all within the rules, but this has set a precedent that could get worse before it gets better. Put the shoe on the other foot and see if your article when discussing a Duck leaving for Ohio State has the same feeling?

    • Mike Merrell

      Sorry, Nw Football Fan, I’m not buying it. First, it was Adams who approached Oregon, not vice versa. Like the Whitworth guy, he has chosen to transfer. And the “issue” of whether somebody is considered good enough to earn a scholarship or compete to become a starter vs. somebody who isn’t is a non-issue. Are you proposing to have a different set of rules based upon ability level? Not happening even if it could be defined.

      Your comment about transfers wanting more playing time is basically saying that they saw a better opportunity for themselves and took advantage of it, just as Adams did. So there’s really no difference.

      Oregon has all kinds of guys leaving early, but it’s to the NFL, not Ohio State — and we support them fully. Like it or not, Eastern to Oregon is a step up. Oregon to Ohio State — a tiny little bit at the moment, but really, the next step up from Oregon is the NFL, not Ohio State, and as I say, we support those who make the step. If Oregon lost a player to Ohio State, I would say that it was Oregon’s own fault and I would seek answers within Oregon, without casting blame toward Ohio State. Or, more likely, I would just be happy to see the guy gone.

      Oregon also supports its athletes who have made the step to I-AA, so I really don’t think you have a point.

      Eastern could have chosen to play Adams all four years instead of redshirting him (for Eastern’s convenience, not Adams’), and Adams would have used up his eligibility concurrent with his graduation. Adams fulfilled his contractual obligation to Eastern by staying there four years and getting his degree.

      At the heart of the rule is academic consideration. It is a sound academic decision to pursue a masters degree at an institution other than the one from which a student receives his bachelors. It provides educational diversity that more of the same from the same professors can’t provide. It would be a slap in the face of the student-athlete concept to force a graduate student to remain at the same school because of football.

      Oregon provides a better opportunity to Adams both academically and athletically. He’s earned the right to take it and Oregon has earned the right to provide it to him. The only unethical thing at play here is Baldwin’s hypocrisy.