Why the NBA Should Support “Two,Three and Degree” Over “One and Done”

utah@oregonBB15_kc-1

Another college basketball season has come and gone, and faithful fans have watched and witnessed another March Madness that lived up to all the hype. Now we have entered the time of year when the players who were so devoutly followed will decide whether to pursue their lifelong dream of playing in the NBA – or return to college for another year.

In today’s college basketball, a majority of the players making these decisions are underclassmen, most of whom are freshmen. Due to the NBA’s standards for admittance, athletes who play for one season outside the high school setting are eligible to declare for the NBA draft. With this current rule in place, a question follows: Are these freshmen physically and mentally ready for the NBA?

Some players will be able to play at the level that warrants a long and successful career. But what about the players who think that they are ready, but in reality aren’t; those who are chosen later in the second round and play a few seasons in the development league? Scenarios like this give cause for the NBA to review its rules for admittance to the league and end the “One and Done” era, instead implementing a rule requiring players to attend a minimum of two years in college before declaring for the NBA draft.

A rule change wouldn’t just benefit the players. It would also benefit the landscape of both the NBA and college basketball, and here is why:

Joe Young, played college basketball for four years. Now has a legitimate shot at making an NBA roster

Craig Strobeck

Joe Young played college basketball for four years. Now he has a legitimate shot at making an NBA roster.

Players:

A rule change making college basketball players attend at least two years of college would primarily benefit the players. Most collegiate athletes are on campus for at least one school year taking classes, and often during the summer. However, requiring them to spend another year working towards an education puts them in a more advantageous situation for the future.

If players receive high grades from NBA scouts, they can take advantage of that and enter the NBA. But if they don’t receive the high grades, the players with two years of college would have more viable options of returning to college, working on their game and at the same time continuing toward a degree.

Vice versa, the current “One and Done” concept adds extra pressure on the athletes to succeed, since they have less of an alternative. Since not all players can succeed in the competitive atmosphere, it is only wise that their hard work is put toward another, more secure avenue.

Dana Altman consistently recruits players who stay for longer than one year

Kevin Cline

Dana Altman consistently recruits players who stay for longer than one year.

College Basketball:

Changing the rules has specific implications for college basketball as well. During March Madness, the same top teams normally get deep into the tournament. But is this because of coaching or talent? If players had to stay for more than one year, teams like Kentucky wouldn’t be able to sign 7-8 top prospects again, and players would be more spread out.

Having players spread out over more teams would allow the game to be less of a giveaway when it comes to teams contending for championships. There will always be top-tier teams, but if players are to come back for a second year, there would be a chance for more second-tier teams to develop.

Students cheering on their fellow Ducks

Kevin Cline

Students cheering for the Ducks.

NBA:

In regards to the NBA, there would be one benefit: the rule would add to the maturity of the roster. Since players would have had a second year in college, those who already had talent in their freshman year would only be more experienced in the NBA. And with a second or potentially third year hitting the college textbooks, teams with high draft picks would have a better chance of selecting players with a lasting impact.

The players selected in the late first round and second round, for the most part, don’t make teams. If they do, they will play in the developmental league or opt to go overseas and play. However, they could have the option to return to college and have another year in the weight room with coaching support, before making the jump to the NBA.

With the futures of players in question, it is important that the NBA not only consider the success of teams, but also the success — and futures — of players. Starting a “Two, Three and Degree” era would not only benefit players by allowing them to be physically and mentally prepared for the NBA, but it would also give them a higher likelihood of completing their degrees. And in the end, if a player’s basketball dreams came screeching to a halt, he would have set up the next forty years of his life for success.

Top photo by Kevin Cline

Print Friendly

 Volunteer Position Openings:

--Media Management/Supervisor:  We are looking for someone beyond college age who can help manage students and mentor in a number of different departments. Expertise is not required as organizational skills and interest in guiding others.   --Assistant Football Analyst: Love college football and enjoy watching it for hours? We need associates to view games and find the techniques/teaching points we identify for them in advance.  You will be recognized in publications, and could have the opportunity to move to full Analyst.   --College Football Analyst: We are looking for Coaches, or retired coaches to help create analysis videos (we do the video part) that will be viewed by thousands, and will help young football players as well as fans understand the game much better. The national recognition will help your resume' as well as make an impact upon the game we all dearly love.   --Video Specialist: We are looking for help in the Eugene/Springfield area to assist with the shooting and editing of analysis videos.   All Positions: Send a resume' with full contact information and any writing samples you have to charles@fishduck.com  Again, these are volunteer positions donating five hours a week each.

Tyler Timm

Tyler Timm

I am a junior in the Journalism department at the University of Oregon and have a passion for all sports, although baseball is my favorite since I played it at the Junior College level prior to attending Oregon. I am a big Yankee, Charger, and Blazer fan and my goal someday is to cover or Broadcast for one of my favorite sports teams.

  • 6thsense79

    Every year we deal with articles like yours with no statistics at all to back it up. 7 of the past 15 NBA Rookies of the year have been either prep to pros or one and done players. Statistically as a group one and done players or prep to pro players have faired better than sophomore, juniors, or seniors and it’s no contest. They provide quality role players, star players and all stars. Carmelo Anthony, Chris Bosh, Kyrie Irving, John Wall, Lebron James, Dwight Howard, Kobe Bryant, Josh Smith, JR Smith, DeAndre Jordan, Lou Williams, Kevin Durant, Tony Parker, Anthony Davis, Derrick Rose, Bradley Beal, Andre Drummond, Michael Kidd-Gilchrist, Brandon Knight, Kobe Bryant, Tyrese Evans, Kevin Love…
    And Much Much more……All either prep to pros or one and dones….all have achieved some level of success from rotational contributor to All NBA.

    Look at the NBA all star roster for god’s sake.

    Let’s honestly cut the bull and get down to it. You college fans are upset because players are selecting making millions over just getting a college tuition. It’s effecting your enjoyment so in essence what you want to do is take away the player’s decision to join the NBA so they can dance for your entertainment and continue making millions for schools. Paternalistic and shallow in my opinion. You don’t care one bit about the player’s because if you did you wouldn’t be pedaling so much falsehood about their success in the NBA and trying to use that false narrative to limit their choices.

    If you and other NCAA want them to stay longer then give them a better offer than you’re currently providing. Allow them to profit off their efforts. Have the market determine their value and pay them accordingly. If you or the NCAA are unwilling to do that then be quiet. Stop whining about one and dones and let them follow the overwhelming successful paths of other one and dones to NBA millions.

  • MAITAIDUCK

    What would make a difference is the NBA stopping Guaranteed Contracts! Players actually having to compete to earn their money and it’s a safe bet to say more young players would stay in school at least till their junior years. NBA is a joke!