Incompetent Pac-12 Officials: How Do You Miss ALL of THIS?

Featured Picture

“Did his head just bob? Was that a face-mask tug on Vernon Adams?” Steve Richardson, a long-time astute Oregon observer and fellow football analyst, stated aloud what I was thinking.

We played the run back and yes, it appears that the defender reached up and grabbed the face-mask of Oregon’s new starting quarterback. A minute later we saw the replay up close and it was very apparent … but no penalty, and not even a mention of the foul by the broadcast booth.

Pac-12 officials and the photo above — need we say more? Unfortunately that was not the only blown, missed, or ignored call in last Saturday’s contest. While I will grant everyone a mistake here and there, the volume of egregious officiating errors last week are too much to ignore.

Oregon had their chances to win, but the Pac-12 officials made playing the No. 5 team in the nation on their home field that much more of an uphill climb.

Simply unbelievable...

From Video

Simply unbelievable …

What you see above should have given Oregon a first down about 18 inches from the goal line with at least one more down to work with. Would the Ducks punch it in in that scenario? Would they at least get three?

Unknown, but the likelihood of earning points from that position is much better than what occurred. There was a Pac-12 official on the sideline and one in the end zone … how do they miss this?

Bralon disrespected by the officials...

From Video

Bralon disrespected by the officials …

Early in the game Adams tried a long ball into the end zone that was just overthrown. Or was it?

The Michigan State defensive back was tugging at Bralon Addison’s jersey the last ten yards of the route. The screenshot above allows you to see how close the ball was to being caught. Have you ever had someone pull on your shirt while running full speed? If so, then you know it hinders your ability to turn on the jets.

You can't drive the shoulder before the ball arrives!

From Video

You can’t drive the shoulder before the ball arrives!

When a deep ball is thrown on time, it should meet the receiver at a certain spot on the field … in this case a few yards deep in the end zone. Those jersey tugs are enough to slow you down just slightly to throw off the timing and result in an “overthrow.”

Meanwhile two Pac-12 officials (red circles above) either did not see it or turned a blind eye to a penalty that should have been called, especially given that it resulted in a loss of six points.

Similarly, I could not understand the interception granted to Michigan State (shown to the right) when it was clear the MSU defender was not looking for the ball, but was driving a shoulder into Charles Nelson!

A defender has just as much right to the ball as the offensive receiver on a contested throw — assuming the defender is actually making a play on the ball, and not on the receiver.

Was the Nelson’s defender going for the ball? Or was he slamming into one of our beloved Ducks and then ripping his arms up to pop the ball out? Sure seems like the latter. Why are officials even present?

Blatant, blatant...

From Video

Blatant, blatant …

The above photo shows an impending incomplete pass, but only because of the interference occurring on the left side of the screen!

The ball is clearly going to the Oregon receiver, but No. 33 for the Spartans has his arm and hand ripping the Oregon jersey again to keep him from separating to the football. How is it that nobody on the field sees this?

Holding in the hole...

From Video

Holding in the hole …

The big 62-yard run by Michigan State on the game’s first play could not have happened without two blatant holds by Michigan State players. Yet the Pac-12 officials were complicit in allowing it.

Above you see Christian French (red arrow) and Arion Springs (green arrow) being held at the point of attack. With normal blocking this is probably a 4-5 yard gain, but with championship holding, it set up seven points for the Spartans.

This view is ugly as well...

From Video

This view is ugly as well…

French (red arrow above) and Springs (green arrow above) cannot rip loose of the holding in time. How many Pac-12 officials were there on the field?

Holding AT the point of attack...

From Video

Holding by MSU at the point of attack …

This is really, really good holding above.

Set Alex free!

From Video

Free the Balducci!

I saved the best holding example for last as I’ve never seen anything like this. Alex Balducci (No. 56) shifted before the ball was snapped, then stood up his offensive lineman and proceeded to step into the hole to make the tackle for a short gain.

After getting beat, the Spartan lineman grabbed Alex from behind at the waist and strained to hold the Duck back!

Is Alex Balducci trying to fly? (Waving his arms)

From Video

Is Balducci trying to fly? 

You see Balducci (above) wave his arms as he is being set up for a freestyle wrestling move; he never had a chance to make the tackle! Grabbing a defender at the waist from behind … and getting away with it? Of course this occurs with the legendarily hapless Pac-12 officials!

It became obvious to Steve and myself that the Pac-12 officials were going overboard to appear unbiased toward Oregon. Thus, we began to assume the Spartans were not going to get called for penalties — even the most apparent ones.

Adams lunges well over the line...

From Video

Adams lunges well over the line …

And finally, the spot heard round the world, folks. You can see it above. On fourth down, everyone saw how Vernon Adams stretched over the first-down line for more than the first down — before his knee touched the grass.

How could they spot this here?

From Video

How could they spot this here?

Yet they placed ball behind the line? Even the ESPN broadcasters questioned this, stating “our yellow line is pretty accurate.” If they were relying on a knee touching before the lunge, the ball would have been two feet back. As it was called, this spot absolutely makes no sense, and Oregon lost the ball on downs as a result.

What about Oregon’s penalties?  

I have no complaint; if we deserve the penalty, then the call should be made. But it has to go both ways.

Why not just let them play?

Then why have any rules at all? Do Pac-12 officials really condone mugging receivers, wrestling defensive linemen, and holding — whether slight or monstrous?

Does anyone know Larry Scott?

My two questions for him would be …

“Are you proud of how they officiated the game?”

“Can you honestly say that all of the missed or ignored calls shown above did not affect the outcome of the game?”

The Oregon coaching staff expressed their squad’s many opportunities to win the game, and placed the blame all on themselves. They are a classy bunch, while fans like myself want to ask the tough questions of our conference commissioner.

That was a disgrace.

Charles Fischer, aka FishDuck

The incredible Top Photo was shot in the end zone (near an official) by Tom Corno

Print Friendly

 Volunteer Position Openings:

--Media Management/Supervisor:  We are looking for someone beyond college age who can help manage students and mentor in a number of different departments. Expertise is not required as organizational skills and interest in guiding others.   --Assistant Football Analyst: Love college football and enjoy watching it for hours? We need associates to view games and find the techniques/teaching points we identify for them in advance.  You will be recognized in publications, and could have the opportunity to move to full Analyst.   --College Football Analyst: We are looking for Coaches, or retired coaches to help create analysis videos (we do the video part) that will be viewed by thousands, and will help young football players as well as fans understand the game much better. The national recognition will help your resume' as well as make an impact upon the game we all dearly love.   --Video Specialist: We are looking for help in the Eugene/Springfield area to assist with the shooting and editing of analysis videos.   All Positions: Send a resume' with full contact information and any writing samples you have to charles@fishduck.com  Again, these are volunteer positions donating five hours a week each.

Charles Fischer

Charles Fischer

Charles Fischer has been an intense fan of the Ducks for thirty years and has written reports on football boards for over a dozen years. Known as “FishDuck” on those boards, he is acknowledged for providing intense detail in his scrimmage reports and in his Xs and Os play analyses. He and his wife Lois, a daughter, Christine, and their dog (Abbie) reside in Eugene, Oregon, where he has been a financial advisor for 30 years serving clients in seven different states. He does not profess to be a coach or analyst, but simply a “hack” that enjoys sharing what he has learned and invites others to correct or add to this body of Oregon Football! See More...

  • georgiaduck

    Spot on Fish- As a fan I have to control my initial reaction, but statistics don’t lie and MSU not being called for a penalty until the fourth quarter was awful. I think if you look at the last TD run by the Spartans Kauntule is being tackled by two offensive linemen. The announcers starts to talk about great form but turn the conversation once the replay shows the hold.

  • Mark Doberenz

    The 4th and 1 spot was extremely odd. They even had the replay officials look at it.

  • SOD

    Great article, Fish….and spot on, too.

  • goducks58

    I have to agree wholeheartedly with you, Charles. While I don’t usually gripe about poor officiating by Pac 12 referees (Mostly because it would be a nonstop litany of complaining about their terrible calls), I thought they did an even worse job than their usual sub par in the MSU game. While there were so many pass interference and holding calls missed, my biggest frustration is with the horrible 4th down spot that incorrectly gave the ball back to Michigan State. When you have the benefit of replay and you STILL can’t get it correct, there is something terribly wrong. Even my MSU friends were saying they couldn’t believe that spot or the refusal by the referees to correct their mistake. Would it have changed the outcome? Perhaps. But regardless, shouldn’t the officials and the Pac 12 strive to get calls absolutely correct, especially those with the benefit of replay review?

  • Gang-green II

    A fascinating review of some pretty low moments in the game. It is a much longer list of missed calls than I was immediately aware of as I watched the game.
    I don’t question the Pac 12 officials’ integrity, necessarily, but this review reveals a remarkable level of ineptitude. It’s tough to lose such a tightly contested game against a highly ranked opponent, and harder to swallow when you see such blatant “misses” by the referees.
    I, too, was amazed that Mich State’s first called penalty was well into the 4th quarter. I guess they weren’t playing quite so cleanly, were they?

  • SCR71383

    Maybe if Oregon would actually get a real defense wouldn’t have to pout about missed calls.

    • Duckman33

      Yeah that “gimmicky offense” is so bad that almost every other team is using it now. You sure know what you’re talking about don’t you?

  • BigBallzChipper

    I”m really considering starting a website where I draw a spot light on these types of misses that are so obvious. We need to find a way to hold these people accountable because if they can’t properly officiate a game what good is watching it. Maybe putting there mistakes on the web, and having there names, numbers, address out there for the entire internet to see would help them see there misses. Time and time again we see examples of Larry Scott’s failures and I’m getting tired of it whether it was Glasses McF@&kFace or the new batch. All I want in the end is decent officiated game.

  • Charles R

    After watching the Oregon v. Nebraska game it is over for me. I can no longer see college football as anything but rigged. The officiating was indefensible for their calls/no calls against Oregon. Why should I ever watch another college game??? This is a sad day, and I’m a Beaver fan.