Oregon in the Playoff, but Major Questions Remain

Charles Fischer FishWrap, FishWrap Archive

Oregon is in. In the College Football Selection show this morning it was announced that Oregon retained its No. 2 position, and will play No. 3 seed Florida State on New Year’s Day in the Rose Bowl.

Rece Davis, the moderator, explained that “we tried to reach Oregon Head Coach Mark Helfrich, but he was in Hawaii recruiting.”  That immediately brought howls from the panel as they assumed he was there to sign the next Marcus Mariota, but in reality he was there to get a verbal commitment from a four star defensive tackle–and got it. (Check Mark Flores recruiting update on Wednesday this week.)

The panel enjoyed talking about the UO vs. FSU matchup as David Pollack commented how there would be “last year’s Heisman trophy winner against potentially this year’s Heisman trophy winner playing in the Rose Bowl.” A juicy matchup indeed!

Reece Davis

From Video

Rece Davis

Rece Davis made mention of the four finalists being “big names in Alabama, Florida State, Ohio State, and OREGON.” (Caps and bold was MY comment.) My feathered friends — we have dreamed of being elite through so many years, and with comments like that, it shouts the question of whether we truly now have arrived? (Do you feel the glow inside that I do?)

There are major questions that remain that FishDuck.com writers will address in the future, as this Selection Committee made some major statements in how the process will be implemented and how decisions will be made.

  • Winning one week does not secure a team’s positioning for next week as we saw TCU go from No. 3 to No. 6 in the final week.
  • Playing cupcakes in non-conference is going to hurt you. It was the demise of Baylor in its chances for getting in, and was Oregon’s reward for playing and beating Michigan State.
  • Should this be expanded to eight teams? The problem with that is that NEVER has their been so much excitement and drama in college football as this year involving so many teams. Eight would reduce that interest and drama considerably.
  • Would Oregon have been in the top two under the old BCS formula? Taking computers and voting into account?  I doubt it, hence the new playoff came at the perfect time for Oregon?
  • It is certainly a good thing the decisions are made after all the games are played. If it had been decided upon in the third week?  We would have had three SEC teams included in the final group of four.
  • Of the two teams from the Big-12 — had they been the big traditional names in Texas and Oklahoma, would that have changed things?
  • Finally, Danny Kanell made the best point of all; we need equalization among all conferences. All teams should play nine conference games and have a conference championship.

I am very curious as to your thoughts on the final selections and process.


Some silly things said by this group...

From Video

Some silly things said by this group …

Top Photo from Video


Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Visit our Sister Site, the new Our Beloved Ducks Forum!

This new forum that is unlike anything you have ever seen between our civilized discussion, (NO TROLLS ALLOWED) complete directions available for easy usage and the delivery of all Oregon Sports News(That last part is a gradual transition up to Spring Football)

Go to the forum where we delve into today’s article and so many more topics and the nuances within them over there.

We have a topic post begun over at the forum for today’s article; it is a free site and offers more opportunity for the exchange of opinions on all the Oregon Sports subjects of the day. (And there are some very cool features!)

An introduction article about the new forum is right here.