Casey Matthews and the Road to Redemption

Joe Kearns Analysis

Time heals all wounds. That and good coaching. Philadelphia Eagles owner Jeffrey Lurie’s decision to hire Chip Kelly as his team’s head coach was a blessing for linebacker Casey Matthews, one of Kelly’s former Oregon players who had struggled in limited game day action during his first two NFL seasons.

Despite Matthews’s struggles in his early professional career, Kelly had trust in him, remembering how valuable he was in Oregon’s defensive scheme shift. Kelly and Oregon defensive coordinator Nick Aliotti collaborated to transition away from the Ducks’ old 4-3 scheme and towards a multiple 3-4 scheme. Though they recruited Matthews to be a 4-3 middle linebacker, they trusted he could adjust in the new 3-4 hybrid scheme. Oregon inside linebackers coach and future defensive coordinator Don Pellum oversaw Matthews’s development into a reputable pro prospect.

Matthews (#55) is the middle linebacker in Oregon's 4-3 front.

Matthews (#55) is the middle linebacker in Oregon’s even front.

Matthews is the left inside linebacker in the Ducks' 3-4 front.

Matthews is the left inside linebacker in the Ducks’ odd front.

Matthews almost won the Ducks a national championship in 2010 against Auburn. He made a tremendous play late in the fourth quarter when he forced Heisman trophy winner Cam Newton to fumble the football. This turnover sparked an Oregon drive which ended in a touchdown to tie the game at 19, only for the Ducks to give up a game-winning field goal at the end of the game.

Aliotti's defensive players, including Matthews (outside the left tackle), crowd the line of scrimmage.

Aliotti’s defensive players, including Matthews (outside the left tackle), crowd the line of scrimmage.

Matthews contains the edge.

Matthews maintains outside contain, but closes in on Newton.

Matthews goes for the strip and forces a fumble that is recovered by the Ducks.

Matthews goes for the strip and forces a fumble that is recovered by the Ducks.

There were some warning signs that Matthews was not suited to be a day-one starter in the NFL. He ranked low compared to other linebacker prospects in nearly every athletic category, as this spider graph from mockdraftable.com shows.

Nevertheless, Matthews’s performance allowed him to become a fourth-round draft pick in the 2011 NFL Draft and he was the first-team middle linebacker on the first day of his rookie training camp for the Eagles. There were a variety of factors working against Matthews that year besides the usual steep learning curve for a rookie. First, the NFLPA lockout made it illegal for the Eagles coaching staff to contact Matthews and help him adjust to the pro level. Second, head coach Andy Reid made the strange decision to hire longtime offensive line coach Juan Castillo as his defensive coordinator. Third, Reid allowed new defensive line coach Jim Washburn to use the Wide 9 technique—which lines up defensive ends far to the outside of the box and makes it easier for offensive linemen to attack linebackers—a centerpiece of the Eagles’ 4-3 scheme.

The Eagles’ first defensive play from scrimmage in 2011 showed how overwhelmed Matthews was as a rookie.

Matthews (#50) is the middle linebacker across from the center.

Matthews (#50) is the middle linebacker across from the center.

The center uses his superior strength to wash Matthews out of the play.

The center uses his superior strength to wash Matthews out of the play.

Instead of fighting across the center to the playside, Matthews uses bad technique to run around the center. He basically takes himself out of the play, which leads to a Rams touchdown.

Instead of fighting across the center to the playside, Matthews uses bad technique to run around the center. He basically takes himself out of the play, which leads to a Rams touchdown.

After Week 2, Castillo decided that Matthews was too overwhelmed to remain the starting middle linebacker. He moved Matthews to weakside linebacker and hoped he would fare better at that position. Instead, things got worse. The lowpoint of his rookie season was when he blew a coverage assignment and left a running back wide open to catch a touchdown on a wheel route.

Matthews is the outside linebacker across from the left tackle.

Matthews is the outside linebacker across from the left tackle.

Matthews moves in the running back's direction, but takes a bad angle.

Matthews moves in the running back’s direction, but takes a bad angle.

The receiver runs a slant route with the Eagles in man coverage. This clears out the left side of the field.

The receiver runs a slant route with the Eagles in man coverage. This clears out the left side of the field.

The left side of the field is wide open for the running back on a wheel route. Matthews is out of position to make a play.

The left side of the field is wide open for the running back on a wheel route. Matthews is out of position to prevent a touchdown.

Matthews was benched after this game. He sparingly played some reps as a backup and special teams player in Reid’s final two seasons. It seemed plausible that the new coach would lose patience with him and he would be a training camp casualty.

However, the new coach turned out to be none other than Kelly, Matthews’s old college coach. Matthews’s scheme versatility helped Kelly transition Oregon’s old 4-3 scheme to a hybrid 3-4 in the past. By embracing a variety of roles on special teams units, as well as all four linebacker positions in the Eagles’ new 3-4 scheme, Matthews showed Kelly he still had value as a backup in 2013 and 2014.

Matthews lined up as the left outside linebacker.

Matthews lined up as the left outside linebacker.

Matthews (front right) makes a crucial double-team block on the 25 yard line which led to a kick return touchdown.

Matthews (front right) makes a crucial double-team block on the 25 yard line which led to a kick return touchdown.

In 2014, a short-term injury to Mychal Kendricks and a season-ending injury to DeMeco Ryans forced Matthews back into the starting lineup. This time, however, he put his past struggles behind him and proved he can be a competent replacement.

Matthews has particularly excelled on blitzes, which gives defensive coordinator Bill Davis some flexibility in his playcalling.

Matthews is lined up across from the right guard.

Matthews is lined up across from the right guard.

Matthews attacks the A-gap on a blitz.

Matthews attacks the A-gap on a blitz.

Matthews takes advantage of the guard's poor leverage and makes a tackle for loss.

Matthews takes advantage of the guard’s poor leverage and makes a tackle for loss.

Matthews excels when he gets a one-on-one matchup which suits his athleticism. For instance, a one-on-one battle with a running back is a much more favorable matchup than taking on an offensive lineman.

Matthews lines up across from the right tackle.

Matthews lines up across from the right tackle.

Cedric Thornton (#72) occupies the right guard, while the right tackle is assigned to block Connor Barwin (#98).

Cedric Thornton (#72) occupies the right guard, while the right tackle is assigned to block Connor Barwin (#98).

Matthews gets into the proper position to shed the block with his hands.

Matthews gets into the proper position to shed the block with his hands.

Matthews gets in position to keep the quarterback from fleeing the pocket.

Matthews gets in position to keep the quarterback from fleeing the pocket.

Casey Matthews 22

Matthews and Barwin share a sack.

Matthews might not be the most athletic linebacker, but he has good enough form to even win a battle against above-average offensive linemen like Dallas Cowboys left tackle Tyron Smith.

Matthews is across from the left guard.

Matthews is across from the left guard.

Cox briefly occupies left tackle Tyron Smith and allows Matthews to loop around on a delayed blitz.

Cox briefly occupies the left tackle  and allows Matthews to loop around on a delayed blitz.

It is not the prettiest battle, largely because of a size mismatch, but Matthews holds his own just enough to stay within range of the quarterback.

It is not the prettiest battle, largely because of a size mismatch, but Matthews holds his own just enough to stay within range of the quarterback.

He is close enough to reach out and tag the quarterback for the sack.

He is close enough to reach out and tag the quarterback for the sack.

No one will mistake Matthews for his brother, Clay, or even DeMeco Ryans, but he is an example of a player who turned his career around in the right environment. Kelly has given him every chance to show value as a versatile backup and Matthews responded by tuning out his critics. When one contrasts Kelly’s stable tenure with the dysfunction that characterized the Eagles coaching staff in 2011 and 2012, it is easy to see why it was premature to write the obituary on Matthews’s career.

Top Photo from Video

 

 

New 2024 FishDuck Publishing Schedule….

During the off-season the FishDuck.com publishing schedule will consist of articles on Mondays and Tuesdays. Do keep checking as new articles could be published during the week when a writer has something to say.

In mid-August of 2024, we will go back to the seven-days-a-week of articles during the football season as we did in the football season of 2023.

The Our Beloved Ducks Forum (OBD) is where we we discuss the article above and many more topics, as it is so much easier in a message board format over there.  At the free OBD forum we will be posting Oregon Sports article links, the daily Press Releases from the Athletic Department and the news coming out every day.

Our 33 rules at the free OBD Forum can be summarized to this: 1) be polite and respectful, 2) do not tell anyone what to think, feel or write, and 3) no reference of any kind to politics. Easy-peasy!

OBD Forum members….we got your back.  No Trolls Allowed!