As a general rule, nobody likes to be wrong.
There’s a growing consensus that the 2017 Ducks are looking at a 6-6 season. In the past week, both Jon Wilner of the San Jose Mercury News and Andrew Greif of Oregonlive have joined our own Mr. FishDuck, Charles Fischer, in assessing the Ducks as the acme of mediocrity.
If the Ducks end up having a banner year, Wilner will probably shrug his shoulders and get on with life. Can’t win ’em all. Greif will probably go on Canzano’s Bald Face Truth and demonstrate some 20/20 hindsight.
Charles? We’ll be scraping him off the ceiling. On this point, nobody wants to be wrong more than Charles does.
They may all be right about this 6-6 business. It’s one possible outcome, and at this point, it may seem as reasonable as any. With a new coaching staff, the Ducks have no shortage of unknowns. In my last article, I suggested that 7-5 might be where the smart money goes. But it wouldn’t surprise me to see the Ducks do much, much better. Here are the reasons …
The power offense game just might be more ready-to-go than most people think. Critics point out that it will take some time to recruit the offensive linemen needed to make it work. Far be it from me to assess the relative talent of offensive linemen. Size, though, I can handle, and what Oregon is putting on the field this year is not your Chip Kelly fast-but-undersized.
Here’s what appears to be Oregon’s starting offensive line: Tyrell Crosby (320), Shane Lemieux (317), Jake Hanson (302), Jake Pisarcik (287) and Calvin Throckmorton (307). That’s not exactly your Charles Atlas lineup of 97-pound weaklings, but how far away are they from, say, Alabama-sized?
The answer may surprise you. Bring Doug Brenner in for Pisarcik, and the comparison to Alabama goes like this:
Note that the offensive line weight of one possible Ducks’ lineup is actually one pound more than Alabama’s. So while it’s nice to dream about the 330 – 350 pound O-linemen committed to the Ducks for next year, it’s safe to say that the “undersized” label is nothing more than historical thinking.
But of course it takes more than big offensive linemen to make a power running game. It takes coaching, and it’s not as though Oregon has Alabama’s offensive line coach. Oh, wait a minute. That’s right. Oregon does have Alabama’s offensive line coach.
But what’s a power running game without a power running back? Truth is, there’s not a power running back in the Pac-12 – if not in all of NCAA – that anyone would trade for Royce Freeman, beefed up to 238 pounds for his final year as a Duck.
A quarterback to make it work? Here is a comparison of the freshman years for Oregon’s Justin Herbert (who joined the team in August and got his first start in October) vs. Washington’s Jake Browning (who joined the team for spring training and was immediately named starter):
The stats speak for themselves.
So, on offense, it’s really down to the dig on the Ducks’ wide receivers. No “go-to” guy.
I had a long phone call with Charles a few nights ago, and told him that I didn’t agree that the cupboard was as bare as he thought at receiver. He rightly made the point that there is not a lot of experience. But sometimes, the newbies coming in do amazing things.
My personal experience – I had worked my way up to All Pac-8 (Yes, it was that long ago.) in the 200-yard breaststroke by my junior year. My senior year I got blown to oblivion by four newcomers to the conference, all with no, or next to no, college swimming experience. Of course it was to their benefit that they were all among the top 10 in the world.
Nobody seems to be considering the possibility that the Ducks might just be “reloading” instead of “rebuilding” at the wide receiver position. That’s a bit of a dig on Dillon Mitchell, Alex Ofodile and Malik Lovette. They may not be top ten in the world, but they were all four-star recruits, and now have a year or two in the program. They should be ready to step up.
Throw in Charles Nelson, a developing tight end in Jacob Breeland, perhaps Taj Griffin in the slot, or Freeman, Kani Benoit or Tony Brooks-James coming out of the backfield, and you have to acknowledge the possibility that there might be somebody to throw the ball to.
But let’s get back to the quarterback issue. My experience as a receiver is limited to touch football, so maybe that doesn’t exactly qualify me as an expert on the relationship between receivers and quarterbacks. However, I must say that I was a much better receiver when the quarterback-for-the-day could actually throw the ball where I could catch it. I’m going to go out on a limb here and say the same probably applies at the NCAA level.
Justin Herbert is an incredibly accurate passer. As a pitcher in high school baseball, he had an ERA of under 1.00. As someone who got pulled quite early in his one start on the mound as a Little Leaguer, I am painfully aware that you’ve got to have a pretty good ability to put a ball where you want it to have an ERA under 1.00. We saw Herbert demonstrate that same ability on the gridiron last year. And that will only help the receivers step up and make plays.
One last point about the receivers. From everything I’ve read, the 2017 Ducks receivers actually have some defensive backs who don’t give a 10-yard cushion to practice against this year. Again I’m no expert, but it seems logical that practicing against defenders who are in your face will be better game prep.
I come to the conclusion that stacking the box against the Ducks to stop the power running game just might not work out very well every time.
But speaking of defense – I honestly can’t make sense out of how bad Oregon’s defense was last year. Was it coaching, personnel, scheme, psyche, injuries, or something else? John Neal and Don Pellum coached many players to NFL level. The recruiting classes have consistently been in the top 30 nationally. So how do you take that and end up 129th out of 128? The only answer I can think of is “all of the above, plus a bunch of stuff we’ll never know about.”
There is no way that the players on Oregon’s defense aren’t at least mediocre at the FBS level. Good Lord, if you want to recruit at the lowest level, you’ve got to compete with the likes of Idaho, Rice, Bowling Green, Akron, New Mexico State, Florida Atlantic … and many, many more who just don’t have a chance to grab the elite athletes.
So I’m going to go out on another limb and say that we should consider the possibility that the Ducks defense should at least be able to rise to the level of mediocrity. And with the punch of the Ducks offense, that should win a lot more than six games.
As Charles and I discussed, there are many possible outcomes to any football season. In August, nobody has the infallible crystal ball. To the extent that we try to be objective, our expectations are inevitably skewed by the way we feel.
The feelings we were left with last year are enough to make most anybody think in terms of 6-6, or worse. Last year’s green Kool-Aid did not sit well, and it has to temper expectations.
Just don’t be surprised when, come December 2017, Charles is gloating about how wrong he was.
Top photo by John Sperry
Mike (Editor-in-Chief) is a 1970 graduate of the University of Oregon where he attended the Honors College and received all-conference honors as a swimmer. After college, Mike ran for the Oregon Track Club and narrowly missed qualifying for the US Olympic Trials in the marathon. He continues his involvement in sports with near-daily swimming or running workouts, occasional masters swim competition (where he has received two Top-10 World rankings), providing volunteer coaching to local triathletes and helping out with FishDuck.com.
Mike lives on 28 acres in the forest near Sandpoint, Idaho, where he has served as a certified public accountant for most of his working career. His current night job is writing novels about Abby Westminster, the only known illegitimate daughter of Britain’s finest secret agent who has to bring down arch-villains plotting dastardly deeds. And, yes, Abby is also a DUCK!
BIG, BIG Changes at FishDuck!
Mr. FishDuck, where are all the daily articles?
Answer: Go read this article right here for learning about the transitory period we are in.
Do sign up for our Newsletter to let you know when Mr. FishDuck has written an article and for his spicy not-for-public commentary. Newsletters begin in mid-October!
Do Register to Post Comments!
It takes a minute is all, and will allow us to continue our amazing discussions of Oregon Sports. Register here…
Our 29 rules about posting a comment at FishDuck can be summarized to this: 1) be polite and respectful, 2) keep it clean for the grandchildren reading, and 3) no reference to politics!