Vernon Adams arrived in Eugene in the fall of 2015 amidst a great amount of intrigue.
The Oregon Ducks were coming off a national championship game but were tasked with replacing QB Marcus Mariota, who was drafted #2 by the Tennessee Titans. In the summer of 2015, rumors started to swirl that a dynamic FCS quarterback was leaving the red turf of Eastern Washington University to live out a dream to playing college football at the highest level.
“Big Game VA” ended up breathing some life into a program that, in retrospect, would have been on a respirator without him. While a retrospective look at VA’s transfer may not warrant a remake of the 1946 Christmas classic starring James Stewart, it is nonetheless interesting to ask “what if Vernon Adams never came to Oregon?”
Oregon Finishes the 2015 Season 4-8 Instead of 9-4
The Ducks were reasonably stacked at the skill positions heading into 2015. The running back room housed Royce Freeman (So), Tony Brooks-James (r Fr), Thomas Tyner (Jr), Kani Benoit (r Fr), Taj Griffin (Fr), and Byron Marshall (Sr). Marshall ended up walking down the swanky hall of the newly-built Hatfield-Dowlin Complex to the receiver room, where he found Braylon Addison (r Jr), Darren Carrington (r So), Devon Allen (r So), Dwayne Sanford (r Jr), and Charles Nelson (So). The Ducks also had Johnny Mundt (Jr) and Evan Baylis (r Jr) at tight end, with Pharaoh Brown (Sr) working his way back from injury.
Not too shabby.
The quarterbook room, on the other hand? Jeff Lockie (r Jr), Taylor Alie (r So), Morgan Mahalak (r Fr), and Travis Jonsen (Fr). Lockie was the presumed starter until Adams’s transfer and represented the Ducks’ best hope, absent the Adams transfer or a switch to a full-time wildcat offense.
With the hindsight of the Lockie-led, second-half collapse in the Alamo Bowl, a 4-8 record under Lockie in 2015 may be generous. Adams was one of the most efficient quarterbacks in the country in 2015, recording 10.2 yards per pass attempt (1st in FBS), a 179.09 passer rating (1st in FBS), and a 64.9% completion percentage (20th in FBS).
Adams’s unique skills carried the Ducks to several close wins, including a 26-20 win at Washington and a 38-36 win at Stanford. With Lockie behind center, Oregon loses those games and probably also drops games to Arizona State, USC, and possibly even Oregon State. Even a 4-8 record following a national championship appearance would have been one of the biggest one-year program collapses in recent memory.
No Adams = No Taggart = No Cristobal
It’s difficult to imagine Mark Helfrich getting fired only a year removed from the Ducks’ national championship game in 2014, but would he have lasted another full season following a 4-8 finish in 2015?
Gene Chizik barely made it two full seasons after leading Auburn to a national championship in 2010 and going 8-5 in 2011 and 3-6 in 2012. Helfrich was ultimately dismissed at the end of 2016 when the Ducks finished 4-8, but without Adams, Helfrich is likely released in the midst of back-to-back 4-8 seasons and never makes it to the end of 2016. Willie Taggart, not yet having posted his 10-2 season at USF, is likely off the Ducks’ coaching radar at this point. And without Taggart, Mario Cristobal never comes to Oregon as an assistant and is never promoted to head coach prior to the 2017 Las Vegas Bowl following Taggart’s departure to Florida State.
USC Still Owns Recruiting in the Pac-12
If Cristobal and other Taggart assistants never make it to Eugene, Oregon’s elite 2018-2020 California recruits stay home. Without the Taggart/Cristobal recruiting revolution, Oregon doesn’t poach 30+ of California’s top recruits, and the #CaliFlock trend never materializes. That means no Deommodore Lenoir, no Thomas Graham, no Austin Faoliu, and no Jordon Scott. Tyler Shough, CJ Verdell, Travis Dye, Jaylon Redd also miss the #CaliFlock boat. And it’s hard to imagine Penei Sewell being lured north without Cristobal on staff.
The Greatest Comeback in Bowl History Never Happens
Without Vernon Adams transferring to Oregon, there is no Alamo Bowl appearance in 2015. TCU’s historic, triple-overtime win over Oregon never happens. We don’t have to endure Lockie passing for 36 yards on 13 attempts, or watch TCU storm back for a 47-41 triple-overtime win in the biggest comeback in bowl history.
But we also don’t get Cristobal, the #CaliFlock, or the renewed hope of returning to an elite level.
In 2009, we Ducks fans were giddy to be among the college football elite, ending the season competing with Ohio State in the Rose Bowl. The Ducks followed up with appearances in the 2010 BCS National Championship, the 2011 Fiesta Bowl, the 2012 Rose Bowl, and the 2014 Rose Bowl and CFP National Championship Game. Sure, the Ducks regressed to the Alamo, Redbox, and Vegas Bowls in 2015, 2017 and 2018, respectively. But here we are coming off a Rose Bowl win in 2019, and heading into 2020 with another elite recruiting class and College Football Playoff hopes that are starting to feel legitimate.
And for that, we owe Big Game VA a great big “thank you.”
Coach Jeremy Mosier
Geneseo, Illinois Top Photo by David Pyles
Phil Anderson, the FishDuck.com Volunteer editor for this article, is a trial lawyer in Bend Oregon.
Longtime Oregon Duck fan with family in Portland. Former Offensive coach at Glenwood High School in Illinois. Team qualified for the Sweet 16, 3 Elite 8 appearances, and one state championship game in class 6A. Currently an administrator at Geneseo High School in Illinois. Father to four kids ages 9, 7, 4, and 2 years old. Coached former athletes that have went on to play college football at numerous schools such as Clemson, Duke, and Army. NCAA athlete at Millikin University 2000-2004.
Changes at FishDuck!
Do sign up for our Newsletter to let you know when Mr. FishDuck has written an article and for his spicy not-for-public commentary. Newsletters begin in mid-October!
Do Register to Post Comments!
It takes a minute is all, and will allow us to continue our amazing discussions of Oregon Sports. Register here…
Our 29 rules about posting a comment at FishDuck can be summarized to this: 1) be polite and respectful, 2) keep it clean for the grandchildren reading, and 3) no reference to politics!