Which Former Duck Would Save the Fiesta Bowl?

Alex Heining Editorials 7 Comments

It’s a common phrase at the NFL level to say your team is a “quarterback away” from being a playoff contender. The same could be said about many college football programs, and although the Ducks may not be particularly needy at the quarterback spot, they may be one all-time great player away from being a College Football Playoff contender even in 2020.

But let’s not get ahead of ourselves and just think about the game ahead with Iowa State. I’m going to give you an opportunity to ensure a Ducks victory over the Cyclones by giving you a golden ticket choice: return one former Oregon player from any of the past 20 seasons to our 2020 Ducks roster.

You can pick any player since 2000 to be a part of Our Beloved Ducks program for one more game and suit up for the Fiesta Bowl. You have the potential to choose a player that wills our young Ducks to a statement victory, or perhaps corrupt the team’s chemistry and costs them the game. While I assume there wouldn’t be many players that could arguably cause the latter, here are a few assumptions I thought we’d make to ensure as fair of a playing field as possible.

This player of course would not be their current age in 2020, but they would be playing at the age (and ability!) they were in the season of your choice (for example, Marcus Mariota from his Heisman season). We’re also assuming they’re familiar with the playbooks, the coaching staff, etc. (as if they’d been there the whole season but injured or unable to play up until this game). And lastly, they can be a part of the opt-outs group from this year. There is no right answer in my book, but perhaps we could agree on one.

Kevin Cline

Buckner as a senior dominated the line of scrimmage for the Ducks

My take: I’d like to bring back Deforest Buckner from his senior season. I put a lot of thought into how the team has been playing, and although the defense is clearly the lacking side of the ball in experience, it was hard not taking a veteran quarterback or getting a premier tackle back on the field like Penei Sewell or Justin Herbert for the offense. I think Buckner is one of the easiest plug-and-produce options of the last 20 years for the Ducks, and would pose the lowest threat to potentially damaging any built up confidence within the position group.

Many fans I’m sure would plug a quarterback in place of sophomore Tyler Shough, but I personally like what offensive coordinator Joe Moorhead was able to do with the team against the Trojans. A real passing presence wasn’t felt all game, but the split quarterback play of Shough and senior transfer Anthony Brown came up big when the Ducks really needed it. We can all agree the Pac-12 Championship wasn’t the prettiest of games for the new Oregon offense, yet the Ducks were still able to find a way to win. I think they can beat the Cyclones if they produce a strong rushing attack again like they did against USC. On the other side, the defense played much more cohesively and managed to finally force a few turnovers against the Trojans, but a lot was left to be desired from the front seven.

Although a linebacker like Joe Walker or Kiko Alonso was a tempting position leader to consider, I just can’t imagine how much better the Oregon run defense would be with Buckner back out on the field. Iowa State running back Breece Hall has been running wild for the Cyclones all season and to win the Fiesta Bowl, the Ducks must (at the very least) slow him down. Imagine how much better Kayvon Thibodeaux would play soloed up against Iowa State’s tackles. Without all the attention from the Cyclone’s offensive line, I could see the pair combining for 5.0+ sacks and many, many tackles for loss.

UO Athletics

Thibodeaux has a sack in each of his last three games…imagine him beside Buckner!

Even considering the production I think they would have together, I’m sure there are some incredible options out there I’ve overlooked. I’m still a student at the U of O, so even though I tried to put recency bias aside, I may still have indulged it to an extent. I don’t believe the Ducks are in dire need of outside help from a player like this to beat the Cyclones, but it certainly could guarantee a bowl victory.

Which Duck would you plug-and-play this weekend in the Fiesta Bowl? Do you believe only one player could push the Ducks over the top against Iowa State, or better yet, could have saved the season and helped the Ducks make a College Football Playoff push?

Alex Heining
Eugene, Oregon
Top Photo By Kevin Cline

(Reading all the thoughtful posts in reply to this article at our sister site, the Our Beloved Ducks Forum can be found here)

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

The Comments Below are CLOSED, as we are moving to the OUR BELOVED DUCKS Forum!

Comments below articles are now closed as we have moved all conversation over to the free Our Beloved Ducks Forum. It has been a big success already with many more posts than what we could fit into the comments below articles.

The Our Beloved Ducks Forum is where we we discuss the article above and many more topics, as it is so much easier in a message board format over there.  At the free OBD forum we will be posting Oregon Sports article links, the daily Press Releases from the Athletic Department and the news coming out every day.

Be a part of the forum and stay caught up!  When you wish to post there, do know that you are protected just as you were on FishDuck. Join us on the free forum right here!

Our 33 rules at the free OBD Forum can be summarized to this: 1) be polite and respectful, 2) keep it clean, and 3) no reference of any kind to politics. Easy-peasy!

OBD Forum members….we got your back.  No Trolls Allowed!

Notify of
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

It’s hard to not pick MM, but based on our last Fiesta Bowl appearance against a Big 12 opponent, I’m going to go with DAT. His opening 94 yard kick off return for a touchdown (See him “breaking the tape” at the finish line) signaled the beginning of the end for K-State. It set the tone for a celebration of Oregon football in a game that was never in doubt.


So many to choose from, but I’ll pick Keenan Howry based on his punt return for a touchdown in the Duck-beav game. :)


Mariota would “run” this offense very well. You put in Mariota in his college prime and we simply outscore teams. That allows the defense to become more aggressive. With his breakaway speed the threat of him running would open up the passing game.

Once that happens, Moorehead’s offense would have one of the best QB’s to ever play college football take over the game. Watching him play was always worth the price of admission.


GO. Ducks !!


One word, Ngata! Try to kick a field goal blocked (7), block with one guy doesn’t work, run against stuffed, could cover a TE, quietly made everyone better, a lot better at 6′ 5″ 340lbs, and ran a 5.1 40. In 2005, Pac-12 Defensive Player of the Year, First team All-American, and I would have given him the Heisman.

Steven A

My choice too.

Charles Fischer, Mr. FishDuck

My FishDuck Friends:

From now on I would ask you all to please discuss the article of the day only in these comments, and all other topics are taken over to our sister site, the Our Beloved Ducks Forum.

In the past, we welcomed off-topic discussions, but now we have the forum for all of those topics not related to the article of the day. (Although if we could make all comments in the forum and get accustomed that all the sooner–that would be great)

Eventually, we will not even have comments below articles on FishDuck, but will have the discussion over in the forum post dedicated to this article. (And we have a topic post up for discussion of this article today on the forum!)

An introduction article about the new forum is right here for more information.

My thanks!