Will Justin Herbert be a Better NFL QB than Marcus Mariota?

Darren Perkins Editorials

As soon as last April’s NFL draft ended, the draft prognosticators began whipping up their mock drafts for 2019, with Oregon’s own Justin Herbert being projected by many experts as a sure-fire first round pick, and even going as high as the number two pick overall.  

Hmmm … an Oregon quarterback getting drafted number two overall. Sounds familiar. In fact, it’s the same spot as a certain former Oregon all-time great who also just happened to play quarterback.  

(Hint: He has the same initials as my favorite chocolate candies.)  


Oregon Legend Marcus Mariota

So, naturally, this got me thinking. Thinking of something so preposterous, that it will surely raise the ire of many Duck fans, and maybe even so unholy that it’s viewed as committing a supreme act of sacrilege by others. But, with Marcus Mariota coming off of what most considered a step backwards and down year – and yes, I can already hear you Mariota homers blaming it on ”bad coaching” – could Justin Herbert turn out to be the better NFL quarterback?  

It’s a damn fair question.  

I know, I know. How could I possibly even consider such a thing? Afterall, Marcus led the Ducks on their greatest run ever, is Oregon’s all-time best player, and — oh yeah — just happened to win the Heisman.  

And Herbert? He hasn’t even played a full season yet.  

But, before we get too carried away, let’s take a look at what the experts have to say. 

3 Thoughts on Herbert 

1) Bleacherreport.com sees Herbert’s presence in the pocket being a key weakness, and had this to say: 

Herbert isn’t a “bad quarterback” in this facet of the game (in the pocket), because he does typically keep his head downfield while being pressured, but in 2017, he tended to drift right into defensive linemen and linebackers, which led to far too many sacks that weren’t necessarily the offensive line’s fault. He needs to fine-tune his work under pressure and find those holes in the pocket to set his feet and get the ball to his pass-catchers …”  

The foundation of this refined skill is there for Herbert, he simply needs to get more polished maneuvering between the tackles.” 

2) Draftwire.com had this to say: 

The quarterback that has risen to the top of many draft boards early on in the draft process is Herbert. At 6-6, 225 pounds, he has the prototypical size that most teams love in their quarterback prospects. Equipped with a strong arm, good athleticism and a good sense of touch and anticipation, his potential is arguably the highest out of any signal-caller in the 2019 class. 

Oregon’s offense doesn’t allow for much looking past the first read, so Herbert ends up forcing a lot of throws and making some bad decisions. If he can correct that, though, there’s nothing that indicates that he can’t be a future NFL starter for years to come. 

John Sperry

Justin Herbert is loaded with NFL potential.

3) And NFL.com had this to say: 

“Herbert stands tall in the pocket and is a very natural thrower with a sharp release, good velocity and a very repeatable throwing motion. He plays with good intelligence and displays the ability to manipulate safeties when needed. Hebert is also a mobile quarterback who can escape pressure and move the sticks with his feet. He still needs to learn to throw with more consistent touch.” 

10 for 10: Herbert’s 2019 Draft Stock 

Some publications did not have Herbert on their draft board, as they believe he will come back for his senior season. I don’t see that happening. With his cannon of an arm and prototypical NFL size and skill, he’s gone if he has a good year in 2018. The 2019 quarterback class is not a strong one.  

Ten predictions for Herbert’s draft position: 

Bleacherreport.com: No. 2 overall, (1st QB) 

Landof10.com: No. 2 overall, (1st QB) 

Sportingnews.com: No. 2 overall (1st QB) 

Draftwire.com: No. 3 overall (1st QB) 

Rotoworld.com: No. 3 overall, (1st QB) 

SBnation.com: No. 4 overall (1st QB) 

Draftblaster.com: No. 8 overall (1st QB) 

Mockout.com: No 9 overall (2nd QB) 

Walterfootball.com: No. 12 overall (2nd QB) 

Yardbarker.com: No. 15 overall (2nd QB) 


Hall of Famer Dan Fouts

Some Positives for Herbert 

A) Size: The protoypical size for an NFL QB.

B) Arm: A strong “NFL” arm with top-end arm skills.

C) One Cool Joe: Started his first game ever as a true freshman against the Pac-12’s best defense (notice how I coyly avoided mentioning “Huskies,” oh oops), and though he didn’t have a good game, he was not overwhelmed. Most would have melted in that situation.  

D) Intelligence: A top-notch student and a quick study of the Oregon offense, as he displayed in his very first game against that one team, and has continued to display through his two years.  

E) “It”: Seems to have the “it”factor, but needs to put together a complete season of getting “it” done. 

F) Mobility: Though not a “running quarterback,” he has the mobility to buy time and extend plays.

Some Points Against Mariota 

(Yes, I understand I’m presenting this in a “heads I win, tails you lose” manner. But the point of this article is to address whether Herbert can be a better NFL quarterback than Mariota, not vice versa. Of course a strong case can be made for Mariota.) 

A) Injuries: Unfortunately, Mariota has missed his share of games so far in his young career.   

B) Turnovers: A problem he had at Oregon, in 2017 he threw 13 touchdowns vs. 15int’s.

C) Overall Passing: A good passer but not as natural a thrower as Herbert.

D) Running: Yes, he is a great runner, and much better than Herbert. But great running quarterbacks tend to rely on their feet instead of their arm when they get in trouble. Though this isn’t a problem at the college level, it usually means that they have a bit of work to do on their passing mechanics when they get to the NFL. 


As the 2018 season unfolds, we should have a much better idea of what Herbert will be capable of doing at the next level. But, as of now, it seems Herbert definitely has a chance at making a splash in the NFL and being a better pro than Mariota.  

In 2018, Herbert could have a Heisman-esque season, a quarterback-desperate team could get the top pick, and good ole Herbie could go No. 1. 

If that happens, I can already see my next headline reading something like this: “Will Justin Herbert be a better Hall of Fame Quarterback than Dan Fouts?” 

Now that would be some crazy talk!  

What do you think? 

Darren Perkins
Spokane, WA

Top photo credit Craig Strobeck

New! Oregon Sports News and Articles Curated Every Day for All Duck Fans!

Want to read all the Oregon Sports Articles in one place? Check out our new FishDuck Feed for Oregon Sports News and Articles aggregated every day for Duck fans and it is free. Over 50 articles curated in one day recently!

The Our Beloved Ducks Forum (OBD) is where we we discuss the article above and many more topics, as it is so much easier in a message board format over there.  At the free OBD forum we will be posting Oregon Sports article links, the daily Press Releases from the Athletic Department and the news coming out every day.

Be a part of the forum and stay caught up!  When you wish to post there, do know that you are protected just as you were on FishDuck. Join us on the free forum right here!

Our 33 rules at the free OBD Forum can be summarized to this: 1) be polite and respectful, 2) keep it clean, and 3) no reference of any kind to politics. Easy-peasy!

OBD Forum members….we got your back.  No Trolls Allowed!