Time For Hope: Let The Freshman Play

David Marsh Editorials 6 Comments

We have already seen some crazy ups and downs this season, and the injury bug has not been remotely kind to this year’s Oregon team. It has taken star players out of multiples games, such as Kayvon Thibodeaux, or ended seasons (Justin Flowe and CJ Verdell), and it has even taken coaches off the sideline with Joe Moorhead missing the Stanford game.

This is only part of the frustration with this Oregon team, and after looking at the injury list, the Ducks’ record is incredible.

Injuries are, for the most part, uncontrollable — but there is one thing the coaches can control: who starts at quarterback. Anthony Brown was only ever going to be a temporary solution, even if he was producing numbers close to Marcus Mariota or Justin Herbert (which he isn’t). Brown will only be eligible to play this year.

At this time, Oregon cannot realistically make the playoff; the Pac-12 is simply too weak, but the season is not lost. Oregon does not control their post-season destiny at this time, though — which means it is time for the coaching staff to show what the future can hold while giving the fans what they want. Ty Thompson. And if it isn’t Thompson, fans would just be happy to see any of the freshman quarterbacks take over.

Craig Strobeck

Thompson is the future of Oregon football. Let him play now to give fans hope.

Brown Isn’t Getting It Done

Brown has shown his ceiling. He has really only thrown one successful deep ball all season, in the opening game against Fresno State where he had a nice pass to Johnny Johnson III. Since then, there have been many missed opportunities where receivers had their man beat but the pass was too far in front of them to make a play. Maybe Brown is making these passes in practice, but he isn’t making them when they count in games.

The longest passes Brown has been credited for throwing have been short-to-mid-range passes that the receiver has then taken for big yards after the catch, as we saw with Jaylon Redd’s touchdown against Arizona where he caught the 20-yard pass and then took it 40 more yards for a touchdown. We also saw a nice short pass reach Mycah Pittman against Stanford, which went for huge yardage as well.

The Our Beloved Ducks Forum is BACK! Come get the links to Oregon Sports articles, the press releases from the Oregon Athletic Department and the news from your fellow Duck fans. It is the only safe place on the web for Duck Discussion, so join us over there!

Brown has been most deadly with his legs. He has made some nice runs — even some critical runs for first downs and touchdowns. However, he has also made some very poor reads and opted to keep the ball rather than hand it off or even look to pass. The prime example of this came at the end of the second quarter on fourth-and-goal, and instead of handing the ball off to the running back or keeping it to extend the play with his legs while attacking the edges of the defense, he just ran straight into a pile of defenders.

Tom Corno

Brown has been good with his legs but is often making the wrong reads in the RPO.

Brown is a sixth-year senior and there isn’t any more he can give. He has been the right choice at quarterback for the first several games this year because he has the most experience, and it is hard to ignore the impact of Brown’s calm and collected presence during Oregon’s win at Ohio State. However, this Oregon offense is currently limited because of its quarterback. Oregon has the receivers to make huge plays but it doesn’t have a quarterback who can deliver the ball.

This offense is simply limited by Brown’s capabilities.

Time to Take a Risk on a Freshman

While a playoff berth was at stake, playing Brown made sense. That run is gone for the time being, and there is an opportunity for Mario Cristobal to instill some faith and hope into the program and the fan base. Thompson, or Jay Butterfield, or Robby Ashford are the future. Fans want to see any of them on the field, especially Thompson, and though coaches shouldn’t make decisions based on what fans want, this is an occasion that would be good for the program while appeasing the fan base.

As fans, we are frustrated watching Brown run around and be incapable of making next-level plays. This offense is unimpressive and right now that is largely due to a lack of a competent vertical passing attack. It is only going to get worse as more teams are going to look at his inability to attack down field. They are simply going to dare him to make those throws as they focus on containing the run and short passing game.

Craig Strobeck

If not Thompson why not Butterfield who also throws a better ball than Brown?

It would be better to put Thompson in, who is just more natural in the passing game and throws a much nicer ball. Yes, he is young and he is going to make some freshman mistakes. Thompson is going to have to learn at some point, though, and getting him experience this year will pay massive dividends next year when the rest of the team should be healthier and everyone will have another year of experience under their belts.

For fans, we can be patient watching a young freshman quarterback have some struggles; that is part of learning the college game. But there will be some flashes of absolute brilliance that will show off his potential. As fans, we don’t have the patience for Brown. He won’t grow into a better passer, and he isn’t the future. The future at QB is one of the three freshmen. Isn’t it time we see what the future for Oregon football could be?

David Marsh
Portland, Oregon
Top Photo By Craig Strobeck

Come join us in the new Our Beloved Ducks Forum, where you get the news about Oregon Sports and is the safest place on the web to read and post your opinions!

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

The Comments Below are CLOSED, as we are moving to the OUR BELOVED DUCKS Forum!

Comments below articles are now closed as we have moved all conversation over to the free Our Beloved Ducks Forum. It has been a big success already with many more posts than what we could fit into the comments below articles.

The Our Beloved Ducks Forum is where we we discuss the article above and many more topics, as it is so much easier in a message board format over there.  At the free OBD forum we will be posting Oregon Sports article links, the daily Press Releases from the Athletic Department and the news coming out every day.

Be a part of the forum and stay caught up!  When you wish to post there, do know that you are protected just as you were on FishDuck. Join us on the free forum right here!

Our 33 rules at the free OBD Forum can be summarized to this: 1) be polite and respectful, 2) keep it clean, and 3) no reference of any kind to politics. Easy-peasy!

OBD Forum members….we got your back.  No Trolls Allowed!

Notify of
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Comments Here Will Be Disabled in the Near Future, so…

Please Post Your Thoughts at the Our Beloved Ducks Forum

Every day we will have a post in the new forum for comments about the published article as we do today. Please take a moment to sign up for the OBD forum and share your thoughts about this article and so much more!

We need a major site overall for FishDuck, and when that happens–the ability to comment here will be gone as we work, but the forum will always be there.

If you were signed up for the forum before when we stopped in March, you should still be able to sign in, although you may have to change your password. This site and the Our Beloved Ducks forum are completely separate and distinct; do not try to use these credentials over there, or try to sign in here for there, etc.

Come to the forum for Oregon Sports News, for press releases from the Athletic Department, for links to articles and for the only safe site to post your thoughts about Our Beloved Ducks anywhere on the web.

The writer of today’s article will be responding to posts in the forum, and THANKS for understanding!

As Ducks….let’s begin the migration! Join the rest of the Community in the forum!

Coach Radcliff_Gary Breedlove.jpg
Duck 1972

I think the coaches know exactly what they are doing. Brown led us back to take the lead at Stanford after falling behind 17/7. Yes he has struggled with his long passes. But his game management is great. The offensive has only 2 turnovers if I’m not mistaken over 5 games.
We would have won that game on the road, where youth rears its ugly head, except for a rash of questionable officiating, among other things. With less than 2 minutes they had 90 yds to go.
It was a tough loss but with losing 2 starters and our OC before the game.
The Ducks offense and Brown did exactly what they needed to do to win, especially with losing CJ again, and I will take that every time.


If Brown is the only answer, then Oregon has a problem with coaching or judging/developing talent. There is an issue, already, with game planning and in game adjustments. Oregon is closing in on having the same issue as USC did, Coach not thinking he has a problem when he has the staff and talent.


I don’t know… I get the feeling that TT is just not ready for prime time and the coaches don’t want to sacrifice him in what could be a vain attempt to better the season. As I remember (and maybe I’m remembering wrong) when he got in the AZ game he threw 3 incomplete passes. And maybe in practice they’ve seen that he has a long way to go in reading defenses? On the one hand, yes, he’s been here since January. On the other hand, he is a true freshman.

J Duck

I think he only played against Stoney Brook, and he made some really nice passes too, down the field.

Log Haulin

Don’t really need to get cerebral on this one. We have all watched the games. Brown is horrible. He can’t throw. Give the guy a clipboard and let him mentor the youth.