Would you do a DEVIL’S DEAL for Oregon Football?

Charles Fischer, Mr. FishDuck Editorials

I remember thinking about it and saying to myself, “Yes, I would take the Devil’s Deal.” Would you?

From the mid-1980s until the 2008 football season, the Ducks were on a roller-coaster of success and disappointment: from terrible seasons when quarterbacks were hurt, to the highs of the ’94 Rose Bowl team and the Joey Harrington years, as well as a whole lot of mediocrity in between. Before Mike Bellotti brought the Ducks their first 10-win season, I recall thinking similar thoughts to what Ken Hulse wrote recently:

“Oregon is not Elite, and WON’T BE Again”    

The despair of losing and not having a consistent high-achieving team really got to me back then, and a couple of us were pondering a “Devils Deal” and whether we would take it. Here is your choice:

“Oregon goes 8-4 in the regular season forever and has a chance at a ninth win in a bowl. The Ducks never do better or worse than 8-4 … ever. That is the deal.”

Interesting!  Would you take it?

John Giustina

Mike Bellotti and Dennis Dixon raised the bar for our hopes as Oregon fans.

As you recall from a prior article, only about a quarter of NCAA Division I teams achieve this objective, so it is actually a good, respectable long-term record.  Some would say it would be the best long-term record for a team like Oregon, considering the recruiting disadvantages, being out of the prime time zone and being geographically far away from the focus of most college football fans.

Being in the Rose Bowl and the National Championship games was so cool, yet we had to suffer for years as Oregon fans leading up to those. Is the frustration worth it?

This past year, Coach Willie Taggart came along and showed us what could be done in recruiting–that it is possible to do so much more. Mario Cristobal will not match Taggart’s recruiting levels this year, but Coach Mario will still break the recruiting record, and he promises even greater results next year and beyond.

Thus, perhaps the frustration in the near term will pay off for fans in the next five years. Should we skip the Devil’s Deal, gulp hard and cross our fingers?

Maybe this really shows two different approaches to life. Some of us like consistent B+ results, and others like to ride between the D+ and A+ moments. Nothing explains that better than the video clip below:

I love that clip, but it does raise that interesting question: Would you take the Devil’s Deal or not?

One of the fascinating aspects of running this site is reading emails from fans, and over the years I’ve had some dandies. One Auburn fan and I took our argument off the message boards and engaged in a intellectual sparring match before the ‘Natty in 2010 by email that began nasty and vicious.

During the back-and-forth, we got to know each other a bit, and I grew to like him, as he turned out to be completely reasonable, rational and very, very intelligent (he was an engineer/supervisor/manager for a company). He was just a big fan of his school, as we are for our beloved Ducks. Additionally, he was a superb writer who wrote with such emotion, yet such logical reasoning. I loved reading his emails–even if I disagreed with them.

Then, after we both agreed to disagree and let our hair down, he admitted something to me that made me aghast.

“I know Cam Newton probably did cheat (with his father) when he came here, but before I die–I would like the War Eagles to have at least one National Championship. If it comes this way, then so be it.”

I could not believe my eyes … he would put up with knowing they cheated if they could win just one NC? It was worth that much to him?

Well Oregon fans … after being in the Natty twice without winning, being one De’Anthony Thomas block away from getting to another, suffering through 4-8, 7-6, and who-knows-what more football seasons before Oregon gets there again, how about taking that Devil’s Deal? Let’s assume a scenario in which you know Oregon cheats but will not get caught, just as the Auburn fan wished. Would you still take the NC?

Brian Libby

One of Brian Libby’s superb books at Amazon.com.

Most would say “no,” as they want to win fair and square, but ten or fifteen years later? Who remembers the “cheating” stuff? All they remember is that you won, and if you don’t believe that, ask Husky fans about their cheating, mythical NC back in 1991. The only people who recall their cheating now are Oregon fans like you and I.

Is the cheating worth it to you?

Look, I love to ponder this stuff in the off-season, as you can really think through the elements of the debate without the distraction of the regular season. I was kicking this around on the phone with fellow “Greybeard” and contributor to FishDuck.com, Brian Libby. He is an Oregon Football historian with many books to his credit, and his passion for the Ducks and his moral standards were as equally challenged in these two dilemmas as they were for me.

But Brian posed another hypothetical question for Duck fans:

“Let’s say the Ducks achieve their National Championship in football without cheating. But once they win it, they have to endure 20 years of losing seasons as the price to the Devil.”

Omigosh. I cannot imagine that pain of those seasons after reaching the pinnacle, and who knows why it happens, but just play along with this “Bizarro World” scenario and tell me … is it worth it to you?

One may ask why we are torturing ourselves contemplating such Devil Deals, but this stuff happens in real life, and we have lived aspects of the situations described above. What is your line between morals and a National Championship? How much pain could you endure as an Oregon fan? And this is assuming you do not know in advance that, after winning that ultimate National Championship, 20 years of misery awaits you.

Why do we ponder such Devil Deals? The reason is because of above; how can you watch that short video and not have the same passion for the Ducks (and the lump in your throat because you feel the same as I did)?

That was a very hard video (above) to record the audio for. We did four “takes” before I could get my emotion under control. I burst out almost crying during the first take, as I was unprepared for the feelings that would bubble up when verbalizing the script I had written. It was years of frustrations and hopes finally realized, and I was very, very grateful.

You and I–we have so much in common as devoted Oregon fans. Would you take any of the Devils Deals?

Charles Fischer   (FishDuck)
Eugene, Oregon

Top Photo: Amazing Moments Photography

P.S. Thanks for being patient with our fewer articles and checking in twice a week to see what is being published. I will be writing once a week, but on different days.  

P.P.S. Look up at the top in the Navigation Bar and see the listing for the new Analysis Library and click on it! Look at the changes on the front page of the site that features it. This first section of the Oregon Football Repository is happening! (More analyses will be added over the next month and I’m pumped!)

New! Oregon Sports News and Articles Curated Every Day for All Duck Fans!

Want to read all the Oregon Sports Articles in one place? Check out our new FishDuck Feed for Oregon Sports News and Articles aggregated every day for Duck fans and it is free. Over 50 articles curated in one day recently!

The Our Beloved Ducks Forum (OBD) is where we we discuss the article above and many more topics, as it is so much easier in a message board format over there.  At the free OBD forum we will be posting Oregon Sports article links, the daily Press Releases from the Athletic Department and the news coming out every day.

Be a part of the forum and stay caught up!  When you wish to post there, do know that you are protected just as you were on FishDuck. Join us on the free forum right here!

Our 33 rules at the free OBD Forum can be summarized to this: 1) be polite and respectful, 2) keep it clean, and 3) no reference of any kind to politics. Easy-peasy!

OBD Forum members….we got your back.  No Trolls Allowed!